Taking grief to a deeply familiar level and revealing its relentless presence, Benjamin Barfoot delivers a sophomore feature that cements his status as one of the decade’s most promising horror directors. More than just an atmospheric exploration of mournfulness, Daddy’s Head evolves into a poignant tale of two afflicted individuals who find solace through their shared struggles—because, as always, misery loves company.

Despite its seemingly lighthearted title, the film is steeped in sorrow as the characters confront situations for which they are utterly unprepared. A house that was beginning to rebuild is shattered when Isaac, played by Rupert Turnbull, loses his father James (Charles Aitken), shortly after his mother died. Left in the care of his stepmother, Laura (Julia Brown), Isaac and Laura find themselves isolated in a remote house deep in the woods, fueling their grief and deepening their sense of isolation.

The two struggle to cope, each in their own way. Having only recently begun her life with James, Laura finds solace in old tapes of their time together—perhaps too comforting, as they lull her to sleep. She, a believably well-minded individual and partner, also had reached the point where she drinks until she collapses. Meanwhile, Isaac withdraws into his own world, filling his walls with drawings of monsters and immersing himself in the gaming console gifted by his father. His father, an architect, had a talent for drawing, and Isaac clings to these small remnants of his memory.

Yet, it’s clear that nothing truly helps either of them. Their grief deepens, and their bond deteriorates day by day. Worse, tensions escalate when a monstrous figure enters their home, intensifying the fragile dynamics between them and leaving them to question how long they can endure such a relationship stalemate.

Turnbull delivers a standout performance, portraying how grief manifests in a young boy forced to process unimaginable loss at a tender age. His innocence is as convincing as it is heartbreaking. Brown’s portrayal of Laura, the stepmother suddenly thrust into the role of a single parent, is equally impressive. Her character is written with a compassionate warmth that contrasts beautifully with Isaac’s distance, creating a dynamic that feels authentic and humanely familiar.

As Isaac grapples with his grief, he turns his inner turmoil into a physical threat—a monster that invades their once-safe space. This reflects his subconscious desire to escape the house and seek answers that make sense to a child his age. His monstrous creations, drawn from his imagination, become a misguided attempt to understand the misfortunes that have befallen him, though even this effort proves futile.

Ultimately, Daddy’s Head is not just a story of grief turned monstrous, but of two lost souls trying to make sense of an alien situation. The “monster” in the film serves as an “alien” metaphor for both Isaac and Laura’s struggles: Isaac is alien to the idea of life without his parents, and Laura is alien to the role of a single parent. The central question becomes whether they will allow these “aliens” to invade their lives or find the strength to drive them away and protect the only home they have left by unalienating themselves with each other first.

What sets this film apart is its unpredictability. One of the most terrifying scenes in this year’s horror offerings is in Daddy’s Head—completely unexpected and masterfully crafted to leave viewers dreading their own homes. The creature design and set pieces are meticulously arranged, delivering genuine nightmares.

For those seeking a horror film that not only scares but also challenges viewers to confront the terrifying depths of human emotions like grief, depression, and alienation, Daddy’s Head is a must-watch. Barfoot offers a breather (ironically, it doesn’t because it will keep you choking along the way) in the genre, preparing our taste buds for more spine-chilling surprises in the year’s final quarter.

score

Daddy’s Head (2024) is available to stream on Shudder from October 11

More Film Reviews