
A news personality shares the shocking story that the reptilian Deep State is using basements of pizza places in satanic rituals involving children. With the government doing nothing– to be fair, probably because there’s no basement at the named pizza parlour– a reporter desperate for a big story recruits a member of a militia to help put a stop to this abuse of children once and for all.
This is a pretty tasteless subject matter, and that’s the whole point of The Pizzagate Massacre. An absurd, frequently slapstick, satire of how the media can whip people into a frenzy over nothing, using dodgy unverified sources as the basis assuming they sound exciting enough. A lot comes under fire here. From Alex Jones style “entertainment” news, to the second amendment, the elderly, conspiracy theorists, the wider state of journalism in new media; all to frequently disastrous results. But there’s a heart behind all this, sympathy is shown where sympathy is due and the real assholes are ultimately small in number.
Tinus Seaux plays an extreme caricature of a US survivalist, complete with an absurd Waco Massacre backstory, that has a surprisingly sympathetic portrayal considering such radical traits. He clearly wants to do the right thing, even if despite his best of intentions anything he tries to do to help seems to end in disaster. Alexandria Payne is also relatable in chasing her dreams tenaciously, no matter the consequences, with an admirable determination. They have very little in the way of effective agency, however, due to the bad faith players of the story. John Valley’s militiaman is hungry for power, and lacking understanding he’s the last person who should have any. A lot of the worst outcomes here are the result of his blundering combined with his refusal to take any responsibility for being a screw up. Lee Eddy’s not-Alex Jones will say anything for ratings, even to the point of surprising conviction in what they do despite how much harm it causes. From the inciting incident reporting on the conspiracy, their news show continues to only fan the flames further. The antagonists just have too much momentum behind them for the heroes of the piece to do much in defiance of events.
Since it’s an absurdist satire not above dick jokes as carefree vulgarity, you’re not in for much in the way of scares here due to such a casual context. The serviceable gore presented does offer some adequate shocks, although the gore is far from the focus. Although one may have a sense of a missed opportunity for messy fun, it’s instead adamant to drive home the comedy as the foremost priority. Positively, the humour is generally successful, this being their central goal. As the budget is small, the comedic focus is more than understandable. Focusing on witty banter and nailing a good punchline helps keep everything moving when there’s simply no budget available for big action set pieces anyway. Interestingly, the true horror here is definitely the state of modern media as a cruel reality, and they do not shy away from showing the ludicrous development of insane fringe culture into the mainstream. The final direction of The Pizzagate Massacre is all the more uncomfortable for how palpable the lack of hope feels.
This is a timely, if at times tasteless, satire that might even do some good if it reaches the right people, although it is clearly content to misbehave for pretty cheap laughs at times. Regardless, there’s more heart here than the concept would suggest, making this an oddly deep vessel for slapstick satire.
We watched The Pizzagate Massacre as part of our Grimmfest coverage.
More Festival Coverage
The Coffee Table (2022) Film Review- A Careless Family Affair [Fantastic Fest]
The Coffee Table, from the mind of emerging international director Caye Casas, stands out as a genuinely unnerving and intellectually stimulating horror film in recent memory. Serving as a cautionary…
Wesens (2020) Film Review – A Subversive Mystery From The Afrikaans Sky
In 1967, four South African Republican Intelligence Agents respond to a mysterious object crash landing on a farm, playing out to offer South Africa’s first found footage horror movie. They…
Fishmonger (2023) Film Review – A Tale As Old As Time [Fantastic Fest]
Fishmonger is a 2023 Irish supernatural horror comedy, written and directed by Neil Ferron with additional writing from Alexandra Dennis-Renner. Not his first time behind the camera, Neil is known…
Mandrake (2022) Film Review – Eerie Folk Horror
“Probation officer Cathy Madden is given the task of rehabilitating notorious killer ‘Bloody’ Mary Laidlaw back into society after she was imprisoned 20 years earlier for butchering her husband with…
Livescreamers (2023) Film Review – Scream Your Heart Out [Unnamed Footage Festival 7]
Not since 2006’s Stay Alive has video gaming been in the spotlight of horror in the way it is in 2023’s Livescreamers. Directed by Michelle Iannantuono, this sequel to the…
Let the Wrong One In (2021) Film Review – Goofy Vampires Don’t Sparkle Either
Horror comedy is such a subjective film genre. Hell, comedy in general is tough enough because what’s funny to me might be completely boring to you. So how do you…

Luke Greensmith is an Editor at the Grimoire of Horror and an active folklorist as well as working in film across a few roles. While this can cover quite a wide range of things, he’s a dedicated horror fan at heart and pretty involved with horror communities both online and local to him. You can find their folklore work on the Ghost Story Guys Podcast, their own LukeLore podcast, and accompanying the artist Wanda Fraser’s Dark Arts series as well as on the Grimoire of Horror itself.